School of Wine & Spirits
All Reviews
340 curated reviews
Writers’ Tears Copper Pot
Walsh Whiskey Distillery (Bernard & Rosemary Walsh, founders)
Writers’ Tears earns its literary name. Oscar Wilde, James Joyce, Brendan Behan — Irish writers and Irish whiskey have been inseparable for centuries, and the Walshes bottled that romance into something genuinely beautiful. The blend of single pot still and single malt creates a texture that’s both silky and spiced, with the unmalted barley adding the characteristic Irish “pot still bite” that gives it backbone. At under $40, it punches well above its price point and serves as a perfect introduction to what makes Irish whiskey different from Scotch.
Maker’s Mark
Beam Suntory (originally T. William Samuels)
The red winter wheat is the whole story. Where rye adds bite and spice, wheat adds softness and sweetness — and that substitution, radical in 1953, gave Maker’s Mark its famously approachable character. Bill Samuels Sr.’s wife Margie designed the iconic hand-dipped red wax seal, and every bottle is still hand-dipped today. It’s a bourbon that proves innovation doesn’t require complexity — sometimes the bravest move is to simplify.
Sipsmith London Dry Gin
Beam Suntory (founded by Fairfax Hall, Sam Galsworthy & Jared Brown)
Sipsmith didn’t just make a great gin — they changed the law to do it. In 2009, London had no small-batch copper pot gin distilleries because regulations required stills ten times larger than what craft producers could use. Hall and Galsworthy lobbied Parliament, got the law changed, and installed a tiny 300-liter copper pot still they named Prudence. The gin that came out was a love letter to London Dry — juniper-led, citrus-bright, and unapologetically classic. It launched a thousand craft gins, and it’s still one of the best.
Tapatio Reposado
Tequila Tapatio S.A. de C.V. (Camarena family, 5th generation)
Tapatio is the tequila that tequila makers drink. The Camarena family — the same lineage that gave us El Tesoro and G4 — runs one of the most traditional operations in Jalisco. Carlos Camarena, the current master distiller, slow-roasts his highland agave for 48 hours in brick ovens, ferments with wild airborne yeasts and natural well water, and keeps production deliberately small. The reposado rests just four months — enough to round the edges without masking the agave. This is tequila for purists, and at around $45 it’s one of the best-kept secrets in the category.
Penfolds Bin 389 Cabernet Shiraz 2021
Treasury Wine Estates (Penfolds, est. 1844)
Bin 389 is known as “Baby Grange” for a reason: the wine is matured in the same American oak hogsheads that previously held Penfolds Grange, Australia’s most celebrated wine. That secondhand Grange influence — a ghost of Shiraz complexity — adds depth you can’t get any other way. Max Schubert created the first Bin 389 in 1960, and it’s been in continuous production ever since, blending Cabernet’s structure with Shiraz’s generosity. At $40–55, it delivers a taste of the Penfolds house style at a fraction of Grange’s price. This is arguably Australia’s greatest value red.
Glenfarclas 12 Year Old
J. & G. Grant (family-owned, 6th generation)
Glenfarclas is what happens when a family says “no” to trends. While other Speyside distilleries have chased younger consumers with NAS releases and cask finishes, the Grants have stayed stubbornly committed to sherry cask maturation and generous age statements. The 12 Year Old is the gateway — unapologetically sherried, rich, and full-bodied at a price that makes the big-name competitors look overpriced. The fact that they’ve resisted every takeover offer for 160 years tells you everything about their priorities.
Dr. Loosen Blue Slate Riesling Kabinett 2022
Weingut Dr. Loosen (Ernst Loosen, family-owned since early 1800s)
At 8.5% alcohol and under $20, this is one of the most food-friendly wines on earth — and one of the most misunderstood. The “Kabinett” designation means the grapes were picked at the first level of ripeness, giving a wine with gentle sweetness that’s balanced by razor-sharp acidity from the Mosel’s cool climate and blue slate soils. Ernst Loosen’s genius was recognizing that his family’s old, ungrafted vines — many over a century old, their roots drilling deep into fractured slate — produced wines of extraordinary mineral intensity that no young vineyard could match. The blue slate literally flavors the wine.
Appleton Estate 12 Year Old Rare Casks
Campari Group (Appleton Estate, est. 1749)
Appleton Estate 12 is the gold standard for Jamaican rum. The Nassau Valley’s unique microclimate — hot days, cool nights from surrounding limestone hills — creates the perfect conditions for tropical aging, where the angel’s share is three times what you’d lose in Scotland. Joy Spence, who has led the blending program since 1997, selects from over 200,000 barrels to create the signature Appleton profile: orange-forward, rich, with that distinctive Jamaican “funk” (naturally occurring esters) that makes it taste alive. At $35–45 for a true 12-year tropical-aged rum, the value is extraordinary.
Highland Park 12 Year Old
The Edrington Group
Highland Park 12 is the great balancing act in Scotch whisky. It’s peated but not aggressively so, because Orkney’s peat is infused with heather rather than the woody roots found on Islay — the result is floral smoke rather than campfire smoke. Add in the sherry cask sweetness and the unmistakable coastal salinity from water drawn from Cattie Maggie’s Spring for over two centuries, and you get a whisky that bridges the gap between Speyside smoothness and Island intensity. It’s the single malt that converts people who think they don’t like peat.
Mount Gay XO
Remy Cointreau
Mount Gay XO carries 323 years of history in every sip. The artesian well dug in 1703 still supplies the distillery today, its water filtered through Barbados’ coral bedrock — a natural purification system that adds subtle minerality to the spirit. The triple cask maturation (whiskey, bourbon, and Cognac barrels) creates layers of complexity that unfold over minutes in the glass. Master Blender Jerry Edwards created the original XO expression in 1991, and it was the first XO in the rum category. This is sipping rum at its finest — no mixer needed, no apologies required.
Fortaleza Reposado
Destilería La Fortaleza (Guillermo Erickson Sauza)
Fortaleza is tequila made the way it was meant to be made. While most modern producers use autoclaves and diffusers for speed and efficiency, Guillermo Sauza — great-great-grandson of Don Cenobio Sauza, the “Father of Tequila” — insists on the tahona, the brick oven, and the wooden fermentation tanks. The volcanic spring water that feeds the distillery carries minerals from deep within the stratovolcano, and you can taste the terroir in every sip. The reposado rests just long enough to gain warmth and vanilla from the barrel without losing the agave’s voice.
Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon
Sazerac Company
Buffalo Trace is the bourbon that proves you don’t need to spend $60 to drink well. The limestone-filtered Kentucky River water gives it a mineral backbone that more expensive bourbons often lack — a subtle sweetness and body that comes from the geology, not from added sugar. At around $27, this is arguably the best value in American whiskey. The fact that they’ve been distilling on this site since before the American Revolution, including one of the only operations to legally produce whiskey through Prohibition as “medicinal spirits,” only adds to the legend.
Château de Beaucastel Châteauneuf-du-Pape 2020
Famille Perrin (5th generation)
Beaucastel is Châteauneuf-du-Pape at its most complete. While most producers lean heavily on Grenache, the Perrins give Mourvèdre equal billing — and it shows in the wine’s structure, depth, and remarkable aging potential. The galets roulés — those iconic smooth river stones that carpet the vineyards — are more than photogenic; they store daytime heat and release it at night, pushing grapes to full phenolic ripeness. Organic since the 1950s and biodynamic since 1974, Beaucastel was farming this way decades before it was fashionable. The 2020 vintage scored 97 points from Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate.
Redbreast 12 Year Old
Pernod Ricard (Irish Distillers)
Redbreast 12 is the definitive pot still Irish whiskey — the one that shows you what the fuss is about. The 50/50 split of malted and unmalted barley creates a texture that’s impossible to achieve with malt alone: creamy, spicy, and full-bodied in a way that triple distillation normally smooths out. The combination of ex-bourbon honey and sherry dried fruit is seamless. The name comes from a bird-loving Gilbeys chairman in 1912, but the whiskey itself has roots stretching back much further — it’s one of only two single pot still brands produced nearly continuously since the early 1900s.
Cloudy Bay Sauvignon Blanc, Marlborough 2023
LVMH (Moët Hennessy)
Cloudy Bay didn’t just put New Zealand Sauvignon Blanc on the map — it drew the map. Founded in 1985 as one of Marlborough’s first five wineries, it was Cloudy Bay that British critic Oz Clarke tasted before declaring New Zealand Sauvignon Blanc “arguably the best in the world.” Four decades later, the wine is still a benchmark. The 2023 vintage was blended from 55 of 81 individually fermented vineyard lots, with that tiny percentage of wild yeast and large-format oak adding just enough savory complexity to lift it above the pack. Named after the bay Captain Cook charted in 1770, it’s a wine that carries its geography in every sip.
The Botanist Islay Dry Gin
Rémy Cointreau (Bruichladdich Distillery)
The Botanist is the gin that proves terroir isn’t just a wine concept. Those 22 wild Islay botanicals — foraged by hand over 30 weeks each year from bogs, shores, and hillsides — give it a sense of place that no factory gin can replicate. The rescued Lomond still allows a 17-hour distillation, four times longer than whisky, extracting complexity that faster methods miss entirely. At 46% ABV and under $40, it’s one of the most characterful gins on the planet, and the subtle coastal salinity at the finish reminds you that this spirit was born on an island battered by the Atlantic.
Kim Crawford Sauvignon Blanc, Marlborough 2023
Constellation Brands
Kim Crawford Marlborough Sauvignon Blanc is the definition of reliable excellence. Vintage after vintage, it delivers exactly what New Zealand Sauvignon Blanc should be: explosive aromatics, razor-sharp acidity, and tropical fruit that makes you want another glass immediately. The 2023 vintage is no exception. At under $18, it’s one of the smartest buys in white wine — a daily drinker that doesn’t taste like one.
Green Spot Single Pot Still
Pernod Ricard (Irish Distillers) — bonded for Mitchell & Son
Green Spot is the whiskey equivalent of a hidden gem that everyone secretly knows about. The name comes from the colored spots Mitchell & Son dabbed on barrels to indicate age — green for youngest, yellow and red for older. What makes it special is the single pot still method: both malted and unmalted barley distilled together in copper pot stills, creating that signature creamy, spicy texture that defines great Irish whiskey. At this price, it punches well above its weight.
Diplomático Reserva Exclusiva
Destilerías Unidas S.A. (DUSA)
Diplomático Reserva Exclusiva is the rum that converts whiskey and wine drinkers — sugarcane honey and molasses blended together, then twelve years of tropical aging produce a rich, dessert-like complexity that never crosses into cloying. At $35–45, it is one of the great bargains in aged spirits.
Woodford Reserve Double Oaked
Brown-Forman Corporation
Double Oaked is a masterclass in what a second barrel can do. The first barrel gives you a solid bourbon; the second one — deeply toasted before a light char — unlocks layers of caramel and dark fruit you didn’t know were possible. It’s sweet without being cloying, complex without being difficult. Sip it neat to appreciate the full evolution from nose to finish.
Glenfiddich 15 Year Old Solera
William Grant & Sons
The solera process is what sets this apart from every other 15-year-old Scotch on the shelf. By marrying whiskies in a vat that’s been continuously replenished for nearly three decades, Glenfiddich creates a consistency and depth that batch-by-batch production can’t replicate. It’s rich without being heavy — a Speyside that welcomes newcomers and still rewards experienced palates.
Duckhorn Vineyards Napa Valley Merlot 2021
The Duckhorn Portfolio, Inc.
Duckhorn didn’t just survive the “Sideways effect” — they thrived through it, because their Merlot was always too good to be dismissed. The 2021 vintage is a textbook example of why Napa Merlot deserves its place at the table: lush and approachable, but with enough Cabernet Sauvignon in the blend (22%) to provide structure and aging potential. This is the bottle that changes minds about Merlot.
Hendrick’s Neptunia
William Grant & Sons
Neptunia takes the familiar Hendrick’s template and tilts it toward the sea. The coastal botanicals — kelp, thyme, lime — add a saline freshness that makes this gin feel like a walk on a Scottish shoreline. It’s not a gimmick; the sea influence is real but restrained, adding a new dimension rather than overwhelming the juniper and floral base that Hendrick’s fans expect.
G4 Reposado
El Pandillo (Felipe Camarena)
G4 is what happens when a family’s fourth generation refuses to cut corners. Felipe Camarena’s dedication to stone ovens, natural fermentation, and unhurried aging produces a reposado where the agave stays front and center. The six months in bourbon barrels add warmth and spice without covering up the plant. This is a tequila for people who want to taste where it came from — the stone oven method preserves complex agave sugars that modern autoclaves simply can’t replicate.