School of Wine & Spirits
All Reviews
1183 curated reviews
Salcombe Gin Start Point London Dry Gin
Salcombe Distilling Co.
Salcombe Start Point is a lesson in balance — coastal-inspired without resorting to novelty botanicals, and citrus-forward without losing its London Dry identity. The Devon distillery's obsessive attention to water quality and distillation timing shows in the seamless integration of each botanical. A gin that rewards both neat sipping and a well-made G&T.
Clos Cibonne Côtes de Provence Tibouren Rosé 'Tentations' 2023
Clos Cibonne
Clos Cibonne is best known for its singular Tibouren rosés, but this white bottling from their maritime vineyards deserves attention on its own merits. The salt-tinged minerality and restrained fruit profile make it a natural companion for seafood, while the textural finesse shows careful winemaking. A coastal white in the truest sense.
Mount Gay 1703 Master Select
Mount Gay
A masterclass in Bajan blending — refined, contemplative, and built for slow sipping. The 1703 honors Mount Gay's deep heritage while showing that age and patience still define rum's most elegant edges.
Herradura Ultra Añejo Cristalino Tequila
Herradura
Cristalino tequilas polarize purists, but Herradura's version makes a compelling case for the category. The añejo base provides genuine depth — cooked agave and oak influence survive the charcoal filtration — while the clarity and smoothness open doors for sipping occasions where a heavy reposado might feel out of place. Style with substance.
Elijah Craig 1789 Small Batch Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey
Elijah Craig
Heaven Hill's flagship small batch remains a benchmark for what well-made bourbon at an accessible price should taste like. It delivers complexity beyond its price point, with barrel char and grain in honest balance. A bottle that earns its shelf space through consistency rather than hype.
Bushmills Red Bush Irish Whiskey
Bushmills
Red Bush is Bushmills' deliberate lean into bourbon barrel maturation, and it works as a gateway whiskey for those crossing over from American spirits. It won't challenge seasoned Irish whiskey drinkers, but it delivers honest craft at a price that makes everyday drinking guilt-free. A solid foundation pour.
Domaine Rimbert Le Mas au Schiste Saint-Chinian Rouge 2021
Domaine Rimbert
Jean-Marie Rimbert's commitment to low-intervention winemaking on schist soils produces reds that punch well above their price bracket. This bottling captures the garrigue-scented essence of Saint-Chinian's hillside vineyards with remarkable precision. It's a wine that rewards both casual drinking and thoughtful attention — a genuine Languedoc benchmark.
Talisker Storm Single Malt Scotch Whisky
Talisker
Storm captures Talisker's elemental Skye character in a bottling that's more aggressive than the 10 Year Old without being unwieldy. It's built for weather — the kind of whisky that makes sense when the wind is up and the rain is sideways. Serious coastal character at a fair price.
Domaine Roulot Monthelie Rouge 2021
Domaine Roulot
Jean-Marc Roulot is rightly famous for his whites, but this Monthelie Rouge demonstrates his sensitivity to Pinot Noir as well. The 2021 vintage gives bright fruit and good acidity, and Roulot's light hand in the cellar allows the terroir to speak. A Burgundy red that offers genuine transparency of place at a fraction of premier cru pricing.
Gran Centenario Plata Tequila
Gran Centenario
Gran Centenario Plata demonstrates that entry-level tequila need not sacrifice character. The selección suave process—a brief rest in new American oak—adds a whisper of complexity without masking the agave. This is an honest blanco that works beautifully in cocktails but merits straight sipping on its own.
Domaine de la Garrelière Touraine Sauvignon Blanc Cendrillon 2023
Domaine de la Garrelière
This biodynamic Sauvignon Blanc from the southern Loire offers a study in transparency. François Plouzeau's estate, certified biodynamic since 2006, produces wines that taste like the soil they come from. The Cendrillon bottling is all tension and minerality—Sauvignon Blanc stripped to its essentials, with nothing to hide and nothing wasted.
New Riff Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey Bottled in Bond
New Riff
New Riff's BiB is proof that transparency in production translates to transparency in the glass. The non-chill-filtered, sour mash approach with a high-rye mash bill produces a bourbon of clarity and conviction. At this price point, it overdelivers consistently.
Glendalough Double Barrel Single Grain Irish Whiskey
Glendalough
Glendalough's Double Barrel single grain challenges the assumption that grain whiskey is inherently less interesting than malt or pot still. The double maturation—first in bourbon barrels, then in oloroso sherry casks—adds layers that the grain base delivers with transparency. An excellent introduction to Irish grain whiskey.
Death's Door Gin
Death's Door
Death's Door proves that a short botanical bill—just three botanicals—can produce a gin of remarkable depth. The base spirit, made from hard red winter wheat and malted barley grown on Washington Island, Wisconsin, provides a creamy foundation. This is a gin that trusts its ingredients rather than hiding behind complexity.
Tomatin 18 Year Old Highland Single Malt Scotch Whisky
Tomatin
Tomatin 18 is one of the Highlands' most underrated age-statement malts. The combination of first-fill oloroso sherry casks and refill bourbon barrels creates a layered, elegant whisky that never shouts. It rewards careful attention with steady, deepening complexity.
Plantation Fiji Islands 2017 Single Cask
Plantation
This Fiji single cask bottling from Plantation delivers the transparency that the series is designed to showcase—a specific distillery, a specific year, a single cask's personality on display. The double aging in Fiji and then in Ferrand cognac casks in France adds structural complexity while preserving the distillery's characteristically lush tropical profile.
Château Peyrassol Commanderie de Peyrassol Rouge Côtes de Provence 2021
Château Peyrassol
Provence is better known for rosé, which makes this red from a 13th-century Templar estate all the more compelling. The Syrah-Cabernet blend captures the warmth of the Provençal sun without excess, delivering a red that is structured enough to pair with grilled meats but fresh enough for a summer evening. Excellent value.
Dingle Single Malt Cask Strength Batch No. 5 Irish Whiskey
Dingle
Dingle's cask-strength releases showcase what happens when a small distillery refuses to rush. The heat here is real—58.2% ABV—but it is productive heat, pushing out flavors that a lower proof would hide. This is a whiskey that demands water and rewards patience, revealing new layers over the course of 30 minutes in the glass.
Wilderness Trail Bottled in Bond Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey (High Rye)
Wilderness Trail
Wilderness Trail's fermentation science background shows in the grain-forward clarity of this bourbon. The high-rye mash bill provides structure and spice, while the bottled-in-bond proof lets the barrel's heat signature come through without overwhelming. A serious craft bourbon punching well above its price.
Fuenteseca Cosecha 2020 Blanco
Fuenteseca
Enrique Fonseca's Cosecha series is built on the idea that agave harvested in a specific year has a unique terroir signature worth preserving. The 2020 Cosecha is bright and precise, showcasing how slow-roasted highland agave can produce a blanco of uncommon depth. No additives, no shortcuts—just agave, time, and fire.
Mount Gay Black Barrel
Mount Gay
An underappreciated workhorse that punches well above its price — pot-still character and aggressive cask charring give it backbone where many entry-level aged rums go soft.
Ardmore 12 Year Old Port Wood Finish Highland Single Malt Scotch Whisky
Ardmore
Ardmore often goes overlooked among Highland malts, but this 12-year-old demonstrates why peat works differently north of the Highland Line. The port wood finishing adds depth without obscuring the distillery's signature lightly peated character. At 46% and non-chill-filtered, it has the weight and texture to reward patient sipping.
Four Pillars Navy Strength Gin
Four Pillars
Four Pillars takes their acclaimed Rare Dry recipe and dials it up to navy strength without losing balance—a harder trick than it sounds. The extra proof amplifies the Asian-influenced botanical profile, making the Tasmanian pepperberry and star anise sing alongside classic juniper. This is a gin that wants to be in a cocktail, but it stands on its own with ice and a squeeze of lime.
Domaine Josmeyer Riesling Les Pierrets 2023
Domaine Josmeyer
Josmeyer's Les Pierrets vineyard produces a Riesling of crystalline purity, the kind of white wine that makes you reconsider everything you thought about Alsatian richness. The 2023 vintage brings a taut, energetic acidity that will carry this wine for several years, but it drinks beautifully now with its bright fruit and stony backbone. A textbook warm-vintage Alsatian Riesling.